What to look for when hiring a payroll professional

Author Kevin Bigansky
May 6, 2025

Hiring the right payroll professional is crucial for any organization. Payroll professionals ensure that employees are paid accurately and on time, which directly impacts employee satisfaction and organizational efficiency. Here are key factors to consider when hiring a payroll professional:

Educational background and certifications

A strong educational background is essential for a payroll professional. Most candidates will have a degree in accounting, finance, or a related field. Additionally, certifications such as the Certified Payroll Professional (CPP) or the Fundamental Payroll Certification (FPC) from the American Payroll Association (APA) can demonstrate a candidate’s expertise and commitment to the field

Experience with payroll systems

Experience with payroll software is a must. Candidates should be proficient in industry-standard payroll systems such as ADP, Paychex, or QuickBooks. Familiarity with these systems ensures that the candidate can efficiently manage payroll processes and troubleshoot any issues that may arise.

Knowledge of compliance and regulations

Payroll professionals must have a thorough understanding of compliance requirements and regulations. This includes knowledge of federal, state, and local tax laws, as well as labor laws and employment standards. Staying up-to-date with changes in these regulations is crucial to avoid legal issues and penalties.

Attention to detail

Accuracy is paramount in payroll processing. A small error can lead to significant issues, such as incorrect pay checks or tax filings. Therefore, candidates must demonstrate strong attention to detail and a meticulous approach to their work.

Strong analytical and problem-solving skills

Payroll professionals often encounter complex situations that require analytical thinking and problem-solving skills. Whether it’s resolving discrepancies in payroll data or addressing employee inquiries, the ability to analyze and solve problems efficiently is essential.

Excellent communication skills

Effective communication is vital for payroll professionals. They need to interact with employees, HR departments, and management to address payroll-related questions and issues. Clear and concise communication helps ensure that everyone is on the same page and that any concerns are promptly addressed.

Organizational and time management skills

Payroll processing involves managing multiple tasks and deadlines. Candidates should demonstrate strong organizational and time management skills to ensure that payroll is processed accurately and on time. This includes the ability to prioritize tasks and manage their workload effectively.

Confidentiality and integrity

Handling sensitive employee information requires a high level of confidentiality and integrity. Payroll professionals must be trustworthy and committed to maintaining the privacy of employee data. This is crucial for building trust within the organization and ensuring compliance with data protection regulations

Adaptability and continuous learning

The payroll landscape is constantly evolving with new technologies and regulations. Candidates should be adaptable and open to continuous learning to stay current with industry trends and best practices. This includes being proactive in seeking out professional development opportunities and staying informed about changes in payroll laws and technology.

Cultural fit

Finally, consider the candidate’s fit within your organization’s culture. A payroll professional who aligns with your company’s values and work environment will be more likely to succeed and contribute positively to the team. This includes assessing their interpersonal skills, work ethic, and overall attitude.

Hiring the right payroll professional is essential for ensuring accurate and efficient payroll processing, which in turn supports employee satisfaction and organizational success. By considering factors such as educational background, experience with payroll systems, knowledge of compliance, attention to detail, and strong communication skills, you can find a candidate who will excel in this critical role.

How Frazer Jones can help in your search for top talent

At Frazer Jones, we specialize in HR recruitment and have helped countless organizations find the right payroll professionals. If you’re looking to hire a payroll expert for your business, please submit a brief and a member of our team will be in touch. Alternatively, if you’re a payroll professional ready to take the next step in your career, contact one of our consultants today to explore new opportunities.

Featured Content

  • Payroll

Payroll in 2025: why now’s the time to future-proof your career

  • Posted May 6, 2025
In today’s evolving business environment, payroll has never been more critical – or more complex. As we move through 2025, professionals in the payroll space are facing new challenges, new opportunities, and a host of technological advancements that are reshaping payroll functions across every sector. John O’Brien, Executive Director at Frazer Jones and the UK’s leading executive payroll recruiter, […]
Team work, man and lady sit together in discussion on interim HR professionals
  • Hiring advice

Why fractional HR is reshaping the future of work

  • Posted May 6, 2025
Exploring the rise of fractional HR professionals – and how they bring embedded, part-time, high-impact leadership, adaptability and strategic value to businesses. As organisations navigate economic uncertainty, leaner teams, and evolving employee expectations, the traditional HR model is being challenged. In its place, a more agile approach to HR leadership is gaining momentum – fractional […]
  • Hiring advice

What to look for when hiring a payroll professional

  • Posted May 6, 2025
Hiring the right payroll professional is crucial for any organization. Payroll professionals ensure that employees are paid accurately and on time, which directly impacts employee satisfaction and organizational efficiency. Here are key factors to consider when hiring a payroll professional: Educational background and certifications A strong educational background is essential for a payroll professional. Most […]