High demand for payroll professionals in New York: over 3,000 vacancies highlighted in latest market analysis

Author John O’Brien
June 11, 2024

As the global Head of Payroll at Frazer Jones, I was thrilled to host our recent Frazer Jones Connect: Payroll event in New York City. The event brought together senior managers and leaders in payroll from across the financial services sector, providing a platform for us to discuss the current state of the talent market and the challenges faced by payroll professionals.

During the event, I had the opportunity to present our latest findings on the job market for payroll professionals in New York.

Our data showed that there are currently over 3,000 vacant payroll positions in the city, underscoring the high demand for skilled professionals in this field.

vacant payroll positions in New York [June 2024)

Attrition rates by years’ experience

We also shared insights on attrition rates among payroll professionals, which stand at 25% for those with 0-5 years’ experience, 21% for those with 5-10 years, 15% for those with 10-15 years and 10% for those with more than 15 years’ experience.

“The data suggests that retention of experienced payroll professionals may become increasingly challenging in the medium term, and it’s an issue that organizations need to address proactively.”

John O’Brien | Executive Director | Head of Payroll

Challenges facing US payroll professionals

One of the most valuable aspects of the event was the opportunity to hear directly from attendees about the biggest challenges they face in their roles.

A recurring theme was the limitations of current global payroll systems, particularly when it comes to handling payroll across multiple locations. Many attendees expressed frustration with the lack of providers who can offer a truly integrated global payroll platform, noting that having to use different systems for each location creates significant obstacles for reporting and data analysis.

“During our roundtable discussions, the top challenge cited by nearly all attendees was the lack of providers offering a truly global, unified payroll platform.”

Brad Law | Director

Another key challenge identified by attendees was the inadequacy of standard reporting features in most payroll systems. Many felt that these reports often fail to meet the specific needs of their organizations, highlighting the growing importance of being able to generate custom reports and gain valuable insights from payroll data.

As the global Head of Payroll, I am passionate about helping organizations find the right talent to navigate these challenges and drive innovation in the field of payroll.

Events like Frazer Jones Connect: Payroll provide an invaluable opportunity for us to engage with payroll leaders, understand their needs, and work together to develop solutions that can help them achieve their goals.

If you’d like to talk about hiring within payroll, your career or the market in general please get in touch today.

Get in touch

Jobs

  • Oil/energy/renewables/utilities
  • Permanent

Payroll Manager

Frazer Jones is delighted to be partnering with an established organisation to appoint a Payroll & Rewards Manager, responsible for leading payroll delivery and compensation governance within a complex, operationally driven environment. This position plays a critical role in ensuring payroll accuracy, statutory compliance, and the disciplined execution of reward-related processes. Reporting to the HR […]
  • Posted Posted 3 days ago

Read more

  • Retail/e-commerce
  • Fixed term contract

Part Time Payroll & Benefits Specialist

Part Time Payroll & Benefits Specialist – Luxury Retail – £35-50 per hour plus holiday pay – 6 months FTC – Oxford Circus My client is a supreme luxury brand in every sense of the word. Currently, they are creating a new role for someone to lead their payroll and benefits function in a part […]
  • Salary GBP35 – GBP50 per hour
  • Posted Posted 5 days ago

Read more

  • Retail/e-commerce
  • Fixed term contract

Part Time Payroll & Benefits Specialist

Part Time Payroll & Benefits Specialist – Luxury Retail – £35-50 per hour plus holiday pay – 6 months FTC – Oxford Circus My client is a supreme luxury brand in every sense of the word. Currently, they are creating a new role for someone to lead their payroll and benefits function in a part […]
  • Salary GBP35 – GBP50 per hour
  • Posted Posted 6 days ago

Read more

  • Retail/e-commerce
  • Fixed term contract

Payroll & Benefits Specialist

Payroll & Benefits Specialist – Luxury Retail – £65-75K – 6 months to perm – Oxford Circus My client is a supreme luxury brand in every sense of the word. Currently, they are creating a new role for someone to lead their payroll and benefits function. To be considered successful, the ideal applicant must – […]
  • Salary GBP65000 – GBP70000 per annum
  • Posted Posted 7 days ago

Read more

  • Retail/e-commerce
  • Temporary

Interim International Payroll Manager

International Payroll Manager – £250-350 per day – 3 months – West London My client is a global leader within the retail space. Due to growth, they are hiring an Interim International Payroll Manager to join their team in a sole capacity whilst they recruit or a permanent head count. To be considered successful, the […]
  • Salary GBP250 – GBP350 per day
  • Posted Posted 7 days ago

Read more

  • Retail/e-commerce
  • Fixed term contract

Payroll & Benefits Specialist

Payroll & Benefits Specialist – Luxury Retail – £65-75K – 6 months to perm – Oxford Circus My client is a supreme luxury brand in every sense of the word. Currently, they are creating a new role for someone to lead their payroll and benefits function. To be considered successful, the ideal applicant must – […]
  • Salary GBP65000 – GBP70000 per hour
  • Posted Posted 2 weeks ago

Read more

Featured Content

HR leaders make exceptional Non-Executive Directors

From CHRO to the boardroom: why HR leaders make exceptional Non-Executive Directors

  • Posted May 20, 2026
Contents Share About Carmen Wee Carmen Wee is the Founder and CEO of Carmen Wee & Associates, an HR advisory services firm. An accomplished Global CHRO with over 25 years of international business experience, Carmen has driven large-scale business transformation and change management within fast-growing organisations undergoing complex mergers and acquisitions. She has led large, multicultural […]

Pay transparency – competing for talent in the UK: winning in the “comparison economy”

  • Posted May 20, 2026
Contents Share Last week in Bristol, Frazer Jones brought together more than 70 Reward and HR professionals from across Bristol and the South West for a highly engaging session on a topic shaping almost every hiring conversation we see: how organisations compete for talent in the “comparison economy.” Hosted by Mike Doyle, Head of Reward, […]

Modern total rewards: interview with Josh Berkowitz, Head of Compensation, Benefits & HR Infrastructure

  • Posted May 19, 2026
Contents Share We recently spoke with Josh Berkowitz, Head of Compensation, Benefits and HR Infrastructure at Silver Point Capital.  In his role, Josh oversees the firm’s compensation and benefits strategy alongside its HR infrastructure, supporting the needs of a global workforce and partnering closely with senior leadership.  Over the course of his career, he has built deep expertise across […]